Categories
Results

The 2024 Osgoode Cup Results: (Winners: Jonathan Kagal & Rehana Lalani, Wilfrid Laurier University)

Laurier’s first victory, Keynote speaker Marie Henein shares her expertise

The year was the 20th Anniversary of the Osgoode Cup!

On this special occasion, we were joined by many previous competitors, including past Osgoode Cup champions! This year, we had 108 registered teams, 113 judges, and 17
schools represented across Canada. With a vast pool of legal talent on the bench, the theme of this year was to highlight past victors of the Osgoode Cup who have ended up having incredibly successful careers. Win or lose, mooting veteran or first-time competitor, the Osgoode Cup brings us together and launches us forward by unlocking the advocates within us.

Our competitors mooted R v Zacharias, a Supreme Court case about whether police conduct after an initial traffic stop breached the accused’s rights under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, and if so, whether the evidence collected as a result of that police conduct should
be excluded from trial. Mooters and judges alike were forced to grapple with the difficult question of how an initial Charter breach impacts subsequent conduct, even if that conduct is by-
the-book.

The tournament’s Keynote Speaker was Marie Henein, criminal law legend and name partner of Henein Hutchison Robitaille LLP. She offered her expertise and shared her wisdom on the tools of successful advocacy.

We are also joined by Mr. Zacharias’ counsel from trial all the way to the Supreme Court of Canada: Rob Dhanu. He also served as the Chief Justice on the final panel of the Osgoode Cup. We also hosted Trevor Farrow, Dean of Osgoode Hall Law School, Christopher Kalantzis, the Trial Crown in R v Zacharias; and Katrina Crocker, Associate at Henein Hutchison Robitaille LLP, and the winner of the 2013 Osgoode Cup.

On Saturday, March 9th, 108 teams (215 individual mooters) competed in four preliminary rounds with the top 16 teams moving on to Sunday’s knockout round. The quality of the
advocacy this year was astonishing. In the end, in their first ever win, Wilfred Laurier’s Johnathan Kagal & Rehana Lalani ended McMaster University’s 3-year win streak and took
home the Osgoode Cup national championship in a hard-fought final against Serena Allidina & Jenny Trang from the University of Guelph Humber.

Rounding out the Semi-Finals were University of Toronto and York University teams, while the McMaster University team made it to the Quarter-Finals. In the Round of 16, the University of Western Ontario and Concordia University all made it through and fought hard on Day 2!

We look forward to seeing who will take home the cup in the upcoming year!

The 2024 Osgoode Cup would like to thank our judges, competitors, Board of Directors, and our 2023 Student Steering Committee. We also thank our generous sponsors including Monkhouse Law; Alam Law Firm; Lenczner Slaght; Miller Thomson and BeMo Consulting.

Round of 16

Team 78: Tamara Djuknic & Jack Newby – Wilfrid Laurier University
Team 48: Sara Moniz & Guneet Kaur – York University
Team 68: Kiara Nunes-Mancini & Zayne Sakkal – Concordia University
Team 30: Atrooba Shahid & Neha Gupta – University of Toronto
Team 99: Sean Mehrabina & Nolan Calderwood – University of Western
Team 12: Maryam Sheikh & Sabrin Saide – McMaster University
Team 39: Navid Aseer & Ruth Oudit – University of Guelph-Humber
Team 17: Ori Epstein & Arjun Thayaparan – McMaster University

Quarter Finalists

Team 91: Madeline Di Re & Aliya Syed – Wilfrid Laurier University
Team 25: Ashvini Giridaran & Inioluwa Adedepo – University of Toronto
Team 40: Julia Does & Kate Hilton – University of Guelph-Humber
Team 14: Helen Wu & Mikayla Mifsud – McMaster University

Semi-Finalists

Team 47: Hasti Jamalomidi & Barbara Krol – York University
Team 21: Anasofia Florez & Soban Atique – University of Toronto

Finalists

Team 38: Serena Allidina & Jenny Trang – University of Guelph-Humber

Champions

Team 59: Jonathan Kagal & Rehana Lalani – Wilfrid Laurier University

Top Advocate: Neha Dupta, University of Toronto

Distinguished Oralists

Jack Newby, Wilfrid Laurier University
Inioluwa Adedapo, University of Toronto
Jonathan Kagal, Wilfrid Laurier University
Hasti Jamalomidi, York University
Tamara Djuknic, Wilfred Laurier University
Guneet Kaur, York University
Atrooba Shahid, University of Toronto
Rehana Lalani, Wilfrid Laurier University
Kiara Nunes-Mancini, Concordia University